Review of a final order of the Superior Court or the Commonwealth Court is not a matter of right, but of sound judicial discretion, and an appeal is allowed only when there are special and important reasons.  The Supreme Court grants allocatur as to particular issues, not cases.

Pennsylvania Appellate Advocate will note allocatur grants as they are made and will provide background on the issues as to which discretionary review has been granted. This page is updated on a continuing basis. Allocatur grants issued Aug. – Dec. 2017 can be found in our Archives.

April 2019

Commonwealth v. Jones, 2018 WL 3598642 (Pa. Super. 2018) (unreported),  appeal docket 24 WAP 2019

Allocatur granted April 30, 2019. Testimony concerning sex crime victim behaviors and responses: Expert or lay?

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court granted allocatur to address whether testimony concerning sex crime victims’ responses and behaviors is expert or lay opinion testimony.

[Read More]

In re: H.R., a Minor, 196 A.3d 1059 (Pa. Super. 2018), appeal docket 41 MAP 2019

Allocatur granted April 30, 2019. Is 42 Pa. C.S. § 6403 (“Act 21”), providing for civil commitment of sexually violent minors, “punitive,” and thus unconstitutional?

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court granted allocatur in this case involving the retroactive application of Act 21 and its mechanism for determining whether an individual is a sexually violent delinquent child.

[Read More]

Hammons v. Ethicon, Inc., 190 A.3d 1248 (Pa. Super. 2018); In re Pelvic Mesh Litigation, 2019 WL 1486697 (Pa. Super. Apr. 3, 2019) (unreported); Carlino v. Ethicon, — A.3d — (Pa. Super. Apr. 11, 2019),  appeal docket 7 EAP 2019

Allocatur granted April 10, 2019. Personal Jurisdiction in Product Liability Actions brought by Out of State Plaintiffs; Application of Bristol-Myers Squibb

The Supreme Court granted allocatur to determine whether Pennsylvania may assert personal jurisdiction over two New Jersey companies in pelvic mesh product liability cases involving Indiana resident asserting claims under the Indiana Product Liability Act

[Read More]

Commonwealth v. Wolfel, 2017 WL 6629411 (Pa. Super. 2017)(unreported), appeal docket 23 WAP 2019

Allocatur granted April 10, 2019. DUI; Suppression of Blood Test Evidence in light of Birchfield v. North Dakota; Waiver

The Supreme Court granted allocatur in this case involving the retroactive application of the US Supreme Court’s decision in Birchfield v. North Dakota to the admission of DUI blood test results.

[Read More]

March 2019

Walsh v. BASF Corp., 191 A.3d 838 (Pa. Super. 2018), appeal dockets 14, 15, 16, 17 and 18 WAP 2019

Allocatur granted March 5, 2019. Expert Testimony; Frye Standard: Trial Court as Gatekeeper?

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court granted allocatur in this case involving application of the Frye standard to evaluate expert scientific evidence.

[Read More]

Commonwealth v. King, 2018 WL 4271212 (Pa. Super. 2018) (unreported), appeal docket 3 EAP 2019

Allocatur granted March 5, 2019. Attempted Murder: Longer Sentence Notice Requirement; Multiple Convictions for More Than One Inchoate Offense

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court granted allocatur in this criminal case involving notice issues and multiple convictions for more than one inchoate offense.

[Read More]

Dean v. Bowling Green Brandywine, 192 A.3d 1177 (Pa. Super. 2018), appeal docket 20 MAP 2019

Allocatur granted March 4, 2019. Mental Health Procedures Act; Limited Immunity for Care of Addicted Patients

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court granted allocatur in this case to consider if the Mental Health Procedures Act limited immunity provisions apply to a patient receiving treatment for addiction.

[Read More]

February 2019

Commonwealth v. Hoover, 2018 WL 4215020 (Pa. Super. 2018)(unreported), appeal docket 25 MAP 2019

Allocatur granted Feb. 27, 2019. Reconsideration of Early Release Order based on Subsequent Offense

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court granted allocatur in this case involving reconsideration of an early release order following Defendant’s subsequent DUI charge.

[Read More]

Commonwealth v. Smith, 2018 WL 4089657 (Pa. Super. 2018)(unreported), appeal docket 2 EAP 2019

Allocatur granted Feb. 26, 2019. Possession of Firearms; Determination of Fugitive Status

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court granted allocatur to consider the Superior Court’s determination of fugitive status to support a possession of firearms conviction.

[Read More]

In the Interest of J.M.G., 2018 WL 2274825, (Pa. Super. 2018) (unreported),  appeal docket 18 MAP 2019

Allocatur granted Feb. 13, 2019. Is a Disclosure that Violates the Psychiatrist/Patient Privilege in an Act 21 Commitment Harmless Error?

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court granted allocatur in this case to determine if a disclosure where the trial court violates the psychiatrist/patient privilege can ever be harmless error.

[Read More]

Maas v. UPMC, 192 A.3d 1139 (Pa. Super. 2018), appeal docket 7 WAP 2019

Allocatur granted Feb. 13, 2019. Duty to Warn Third Parties of Danger Posed by Mental Health Patient

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court will consider whether mental health professionals have a duty to warn unidentified neighbors of a mental health patient of possible risk.

[Read More]

Com. v. Hamlett, 2018 WL 4327391 (Pa. Super. 2018) (unreported), appeal docket 8 WAP 2019

Allocatur granted Feb. 13, 2019. Sua Sponte Raising of Harmless Error; Right for Any Reason Doctrine

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court granted allocatur in this criminal case to determine issues related to harmless error and the right for any reason doctrine.

[Read More]

In Re: The Estate of William K. McAleer, 194 A.3d 587 (Pa. Super. 2018), appeal docket 6 WAP 2019

Allocatur granted Feb. 4, 2019.  Attorney-client Privilege; Administration of Trusts.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court granted allocatur to determine whether attorney-client privilege and work product doctrines protect communications between a trustee and counsel from discovery by beneficiaries.

[Read More]

Easton Area Sch. Dist. v. Miller, 191 A.3d 75 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2018), appeal docket 13 MAP 2019

Allocatur granted Feb. 4, 2019.  Right to Know Law; Disclosure of School Bus Surveillance Video under Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act

The Supreme Court granted allocatur in this case involving public disclosure of school bus security footage pursuant to the RTKL.

[Read More]

January 2019

Assouline v. Reynolds, 184 A.3d 970 (Pa. Super. 2018), allocatur granted Jan. 29, 2019, appeal docket 5 WAP 2019

Allocatur granted Jan. 29, 2019.  Jurisdiction; Landlord Tenant Dispute without a Lease

The Supreme Court granted allocatur in this case involving subject matter jurisdiction in landlord tenant action before the magistrate.

[Read More]

Seda-Cog Joint Rail Authority v. Carload Express, Inc., 185 A.3d 1232 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2018), appeal docket 12 MAP 2019

Allocatur granted Jan. 23, 2019.  Municipalities Authorities Act: “Majority” Needed to Take Action

The Supreme Court granted allocatur in this case involving application of the majority voting requirement pursuant to the MAA.

[Read More]

Trigg v. Children’s Hosp. of Pittsburgh of UPMC, 187 A.3d 1013 (Pa. Super. 2018), appeal docket 3 WAP 2019

Allocatur granted Jan. 23, 2019.  Jury Selection; McHugh Deference

The Supreme Court granted allocatur in this case to address issues related to the application of the McHugh deference standard. 

[Read More]

City of Pittsburgh v. Fraternal Order of Police Fort Pitt Lodge No. 1, 189 A.3d 491 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2018), appeal docket 2 WAP 2019

Allocatur granted Jan. 16, 2019.  Act 111; Arbitrator’s Authority in a Grievance Arbitration

The Supreme Court granted allocatur in this case to address the scope of authority of the arbitrator in an Act 111 grievance arbitration. 

[Read More]

Crown Castle NG East, LLC v. Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission, 188 A.3d 617 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2018),  appeal docket 2 MAP 2019

Allocatur granted Jan. 3, 2019.  Definition of “Public Utility”; DAS Service vs. Cell Phone Service; Agency Deference; Statutory Construction

The Supreme Court granted allocatur in this appeal of a Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission decision regarding DAS provider Crown Castle.

[Read More]

Young v. Pennsylvania Board of Probation and Parole, 189 A.3d 16 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2018), appeal docket 1 MAP 2019

Allocatur granted Jan. 2, 2019.  Statutory Interpretation; Sentence Credit Revocation Under the Parole Code

The Supreme Court granted allocatur in this appeal involving the revocation of earned sentence credit under the Parole Code.

[Read More]

December 2018

Commonwealth v. Rivera, Nos. 792 MDA 2017; 793 MDA 2017 (Pa. Super. 2018) (unreported) (consolidated), appeal dockets 78 MAP 2018, 79 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Dec. 28, 2018.  Double Jeopardy; Prosecutorial Misconduct; Standard of Review

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine the standard of review applicable to a determination of prosecutorial misconduct.

[Read More]

Barnard v. The Travelers Home and Marine Ins. Co., 2018 WL 6807257, docket 42 EAP 2018

Petition of the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit granted Dec. 27, 2018.  Stacking UIM Benefits; Need for New Waiver Where Policy Limits Increased

The Supreme Court granted certification of a question from the Third Circuit related to Pennsylvania law on insurance benefit stacking.

[Read More]

Lowman v. UCBR, 178 A.3d 896 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2018), appeal docket 41 EAP 2018

Allocatur granted Dec. 27, 2018. Unemployment Compensation; Ineligibility due to Self-Employment

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur in this case to consider eligibility for unemployment compensation when a claimant is involved in providing ride-sharing services.

[Read More]

Commonwealth v. Diaz, 183 A.3d 417 (Pa. Super. 2018), appeal docket 74 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Dec. 19, 2018. Post-Conviction Relief and Ineffectiveness of Counsel for Failure to Obtain an Interpreter

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur in this PCRA case involving an ineffective assistance of counsel claim based on counsel’s failure to secure an interpreter for the first day of trial. 

[Read More]


Commonwealth v. Johnson, 2018 WL 3133226 (Pa. Super. 2018) (unreported), appeal docket 40 EAP 2018

Allocatur granted Dec. 19, 2018. Double Jeopardy; Prosecutorial Misconduct

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur in this criminal case involving prosecutorial misconduct. 

[Read More]

Navarro v. Pennsylvania State Police, 2018 WL 2247193 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2018) (unreported), appeal docket 72 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Dec. 18, 2018. PSP’s Burden on Appeal from Denial of Return of Firearm

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine PSP’s burden on appeal from the denial of the return of a firearm.

[Read More]

Commonwealth v. Smith, 2018 WL 2111007 (Pa. Super. 2018) (unreported), appeal docket 73 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Dec. 18, 2018. Sufficiency of Evidence to Support Conviction for Possession of Firearm with Altered Manufacturer’s Number

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur in this criminal case involving a conviction for possession of a firearm with an altered manufacturer’s number pursuant to 18 Pa.C.S. § 6110.2.

[Read More]

Ass’n of Pa. State Coll. & Univ. Faculties v. Pa. Labor Relations Bd., 2018 WL 1868303 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2018) (unreported), appeal docket 67 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Dec. 15, 2018. Collective Bargaining; Nonbargainable Managerial Prerogative

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur in this collective bargaining case involving consideration of managerial prerogatives.

[Read More]

Commonwealth v. Mock, 186 A.3d 434 (Pa. Super. 2018), appeal docket 68 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Dec. 5, 2018. DUI:  Ten Year Rule Applies from Conviction or Commission of Prior Offense

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur in this DUI case involving grading in consideration of a prior offense.

[Read More]

In Re: Estate of Krasinski, 188 A.3d 461 (Pa. Super. 2018) (en banc),  appeal docket 40 WAP 2018 

Allocatur granted Dec. 4, 2018. Waiver; Estate Law

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine issues involving estate orders “Determining an Interest in Real or Personal Property” under Pa. R.A.P. 342(a)(6).

[Read More]

Pennsylvania State Police v. American Civil Liberties Union of Pa., 2018 WL 2272597 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2018) (unreported), appeal docket 66 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Dec. 3, 2018. RTKL; Sufficiency of Evidence; In Camera Review

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur in this Right to Know law case on issues involving the sufficiency of evidence and use of in camera review.

[Read More]

November 2018

City of Harrisburg v. Prince, 186 A.3d 544 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2018), appeal docket 62 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Nov. 20, 2018. RTKL; Disclosure of Financial Records

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine whether  the City of Harrisburg’s creation of a spreadsheet shows the receipt of funds from donors to the “Protect Harrisburg Legal Defense Fund” constitute a “financial record” as defined in 65 P.S. § 67.102?

[Read More]

October 2018

Commonwealth v. Trahey, 183 A.3d 444 (Pa. Super. 2018), appeal docket 38 EAP 2018

Allocatur granted Oct. 23, 2018. Warrantless Blood Test; Exigent Circumstances Exception to the Warrant Requirement

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine whether the facts and circumstances in this case justify a warrantless blood draw under the exigent circumstances exception to the warrant requirement.

[Read More]

Commonwealth v. Bishop, 2018 WL 3121801 (Pa. Super. 2018) (unpublished), appeal docket 37 EAP 2018

Allocatur granted Oct. 17, 2018. Right against Self-incrimination; Physical Evidence Recovered as a Result of an Unwarned Statement

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court granted allocatur to determine whether the Pennsylvania Constitution extends greater protection than its federal counterpart with respect to the Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination in the context of physical evidence recovered as a result of or during the course of an unwarned statement?

[Read More]

Bartkowski v. Ramondo, 2018 WL 495213 (Pa. Super. 2018) (unreported), appeal docket 60 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Oct. 16, 2018. Easement by Necessity; Impossibility of Alternative Access

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur in this zoning case involving an easement by necessity.

[Read More]

Sayles v. Allstate Ins. Co., 260 F.Supp.3d 427 (M.D.Pa. 2017); Scott v. Travelers Commercial Ins. Co., 2017 WL 6403010 (M.D. Pa. 2017), appeal dockets 58 and 59 MAP 2018 

Petition of the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit granted Oct. 15, 2018. Auto Insurance; Apparent Conflict Between Mandatory IME Requirement and Section 1796(a) of the MVFRL

In this certification of a question from the Third Circuit, the Supreme Court will consider whether an insurer’s medical examination provision is in direct conflict with Section 1796(a) of the MVFRL.

[Read More]

Commonwealth v. Tighe, 184 A.3d 560 (Pa. Super. 2018), appeal docket 57 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Oct. 15, 2018. Right to Self-Representation; Limitations Absent Waiver

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur in this case involving limitations on the right to self-representation in a criminal trial.

[Read More]

Commonwealth v. Davis, 176 A.3d 869 (Pa. Super. 2017), appeal docket 56 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Oct. 3, 2018. Fifth Amendment; Forgone Conclusion Doctrine; Compelling Disclosure of Digital Password

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine whether a individual can be compelled to disclose a memorized password over his assertion of Fifth Amendment privilege.

[Read More]

US Airways, Inc. v. WCAB (Bockelman), 179 A.3d 1177 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2018), appeal docket 35 WAP 2018

Allocatur granted Oct. 3, 2018. Workers’ Compensation; Scope of Employment

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur in this workers’ compensation case involving a determination of what constitutes the “premises” of an employer.

[Read More]

Thompson v. Thompson, 187 A.3d 259 (Pa. Super. 2018), appeal docket 36 WAP 2018

Allocatur granted Oct. 3, 2018. Child Support; Civil Contempt; Sentencing

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur in this case involving a suspended sentence imposed for contempt of a custody order.

[Read More]

City of Phila. v. Galdo, 181 A.3d 1289 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2018), appeal docket 36 EAP 2018

Allocatur granted Oct. 2, 2018. Public-purpose Condemnation; Adverse Possession

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur in this case involving the applicability of adverse possession to property acquired by the City through a public-purpose condemnation designed to assist the Commonwealth with the construction of I-95, and then held for subsequent resale.

[Read More]

Commonwealth v. Britton, 2018 WL 1165543 (Pa. Super. 2018) (unreported), appeal docket 55 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Oct. 2, 2018. Out of State Law Enforcement; Applicability of Pennsylvania Law

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur in this case involving the applicability of Pennsylvania standards to out of state law enforcement officials acting in their own state at the request of Pennsylvania officials. 

[Read More]

September 2018

Commonwealth v. Byrd, 185 A.3d 1015 (Pa. Super. 2018), appeal docket 34 WAP 2018

Allocatur granted Sept. 19, 2018. Wiretap Act; Jailhouse Communications

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur in this case involving the application of Pennsylvania’s Wiretap Act to jailhouse communications.

[Read More]

In Re: Petition of J.M.Y., 179 A.3d 1140 (Pa. Super. 2018) (en banc), appeal docket 33 WAP 2018 

Allocatur granted Sept. 17, 2018. Mental Health Procedures Act; Review of Section 303 Commitment after Expiration of Appeal Period

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine whether the Pennsylvania Superior Court erred when it exercised jurisdiction to review a commitment under 50 P.S. § 7303, when no timely appeal was filed, and the challenge was brought years later under the Pennsylvania Uniform Firearms Act.

[Read More]

Exeter Twp. v. PLRB, 177 A.3d 428 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2018), appeal dockets 49 and 50 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Sept. 5, 2018. Public Employees: Are Township Zoning Officers Management by Statute?

The Supreme Court will determine whether the MPC provides a sufficient basis to determine that a zoning officer is a management level employee.

[Read More]

August 2018

Grove v. Port Auth. Of Allegheny Cty., 178 A.3d 239 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2018), appeal docket 32 WAP 2018

Allocatur granted Aug. 31, 2018. Negligence Per Se; Jury Instruction

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur in this case arising a pedestrian crosswalk accident in Pittsburgh.

[Read More]

Binswanger of Pennsylvania, Inc. v. TSG Real Estate LLC, 2017 WL 6568779 (Pa. Super. 2017), appeal docket 30 EAP 2018

Allocatur granted Aug. 30, 2018. Real Estate; Occurrence of Sale by Equitable conversion where Agreement of Sale Conditional

The Supreme Court granted allocatur on this case involving equitable conversion in the sale of real estate in Pennsylvania.

[Read More]

Commonwealth v. Peters, 2018 WL 617947 (Pa. Super 2018) (unreported), appeal docket 29 EAP 2018

Allocatur granted Aug. 30, 2018. Constructive Possession of Instrument of a Crime

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur in this case involving constructive “possession of an instrument of crime.”

[Read More]

In re: 2014 Allegheny Cty. Investigating Grand Jury, 181 A.3d 349 (Pa. Super. 2018), appeal docket 30 WAP 2018

Allocatur granted Aug. 29, 2018. Public Access to Grand Jury Documents

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur in this case involving WPXI’s request for public access to unsealed grand jury documents.

[Read More]

Com. v.  Turpin, 2018 WL 831889 (Pa. Super. 2018) (unreported), appeal docket 45 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Aug. 21, 2018. Scope of Search of Multi-Occupant Residence Where Warrant Based on Activity of Only One Occupant

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court granted allocatur to consider whether a warrant based on the activity of one occupant of a multi-occupant residence permits the search of the entirety of a multi-occupant residence. 

[Read More]

Gamesa Energy USA v. Ten Penn Center Assocs. L.P., 181 A.3d 1188 (Pa. Super. 2018), appeal docket 28 EAP 2018

Allocatur granted Aug. 20, 2018. Leases; Election of Remedies

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur in this case involving a commercial landlord/tenant dispute.

[Read More]

Commonwealth v. Olson, 179 A.3d 1134 (Pa. Super. 2018), appeal docket 26 WAP 2018

Allocatur granted Aug. 7, 2018. DUI; Post Conviction Relief, Retroactive Application of Birchfield v. North Dakota

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine the retroactive applicability of the United States Supreme Court decision in Birchfield v. North Dakota.

[Read More]


Elliott Menkowitz, M.D. v. Peerless Publications, Inc., 176 A.3d 968 (Pa. Super. 2017), appeal docket 40 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Aug. 1, 2018. Private-Figure Defamation; The Joseph Standard

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine the appropriate standards of causation and deference involving defamation of private figures.

[Read More]

Berner v. Montour Twp. Zoning Hearing Bd., 176 A.3d 1058 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2018), appeal docket 39 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Aug. 1, 2018. Nutrient Management Act; Preemption of Local Zoning Ordinances

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine whether the United States Supreme Court holding in Birchfield v. North Dakota should retroactively apply to all cases not yet final when the decision was rendered.

[Read More]

July 2018

Commonwealth v. Butler, 173 A.3d 1212 (Pa. Super. 2017), appeal docket 25 WAP 2018

Allocatur granted July 31, 2018. Constitutionality of Sexually Violent Predator Hearings and Designations

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine the constitutionality of SVP hearings and designations.

[Read More]


Roverano v. John Crane, Inc., 177 A3d 892 (Pa. Super. 2017), appeal docket 26 EAP 2018

Allocatur granted July 31, 2018. Fair Share Act Strict Liability Verdict Apportionment

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine issues of first impression related to the apportionment of liability among joint tortfeasors pursuant to Pennsylvania’s Fair Share Act.

[Read More]


Commonwealth v. Hays, 2018 WL 481895 (Pa. Super. 2018) (unreported), appeal docket 36 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted July 24, 2018. DUI; Retroactive Application of Birchfield v. North Dakota

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine whether the United States Supreme Court holding in Birchfield v. North Dakota should retroactively apply to all cases not yet final when the decision was rendered.

[Read More]

Estate of L. Wilson v. State Emps. Ret. Bd., 177 A.3d 1020 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2017), appeal docket 21 WAP 2018

Allocatur granted July 16, 2018. State Employees’ Retirement Code; Administrative Law

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine whether the Commonwealth Court abused its discretion and departed from accepted judicial practice in holding that the Decedent’s retirement option change application must be considered filed when mailed.

[Read More]

In Re: Risperdal Litigation, 2017 WL 5256400 (Pa. Super. 2017) (unreported), appeal dockets 22 EAP 2018 (Saksek) and 23 EAP 2018 (Winter)

Allocatur granted July 5, 2018. Statute of Limitations: When is the Discovery Rule a Question of Fact for the Jury Such that Summary Judgment is Improper?

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court granted allocatur to consider whether a jury should have been permitted to consider the applicability of the discovery rule to the statute of limitations in this mass tort litigation.

[Read More]

June 2018

Com. v. Williams, 2017 WL 6545977 (Pa. Super. 2017), appeal docket 20 EAP 2018

Allocatur granted June 25, 2018. Criminal Voir Dire; Questions Concerning Attitudes about Gun Violence

The Supreme Court granted allocatur to determine whether the trial court abused its discretion in precluding the questioning of jurors about their views on guns and gun violence during voir dire.

[Read More]

Commonwealth v. Felder, 2017 WL 6505643 (Pa. Super. 2017) (unreported), appeal docket 18 EAP 2018

Allocatur granted June 19, 2018. Constitutionality of Juvenile Sentencing

The Supreme Court granted allocatur to review the constitutionality of a sentence of 50-years to life for a juvenile in light of its decision in Commonwealth v. Batts, 163 A.3d 410 (Pa. 2017).

[Read More]

Justice v. Lombardo, 173 A.3d 1230 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2017), appeal docket 16 EAP 2018

Allocatur granted June 5, 2018. Scope of Employment; Sovereign Immunity

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine whether Respondent was acting within the scope of his employment throughout his entire encounter with the motorist, and thus entitled to JNOV on the basis of sovereign immunity

[Read More]

Safe Auto Ins. Co. v. Oriental-Guillermo, 170 A.3d 1170 (Pa. Super. 2017), appeal docket 26 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted June 4, 2018. PA Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law (MVFRL); Auto Insurance Liability

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine issues related to auto insurance liability under PA Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law (MVFRL) for unlisted resident drivers.

[Read More]

April 2018

Germantown Cab Co. v. Philadelphia Parking Auth., 171 A.3d 315 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2017), appeal dockets 14 and 15 EAP 2018

Allocatur granted Apr. 30, 2018. Partial Rights Taxicabs; Assessments; Unconstitutional Delegation of Legislative Power; Substantive Due Process

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine issues related to the Pennsylvania Parking Authority’s annual assessments for fiscal year 2015 imposed upon partial rights taxicabs pursuant to Section 5707 of the Parking Authorities Law.

[Read More]

Commonwealth. v. King, 167 A.3d 140 (Pa. Super. 2017), appeal docket 13 EAP 2018

Allocatur granted Apr. 30, 2018.  PCRA; Ineffective Assistance of Counsel; Attorney-Client Privilege

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine whether PCRA courts may bar the Commonwealth from speaking with a defendant’s trial counsel prior to evidentiary hearings on defense claims that counsel provided ineffective assistance.

[Read More]

Gifford v. Commonwealth of Pa., Dep’t of Trans., Bureau of Driver Licensing, 172 A.3d 727 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2017), appeal docket 19 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Apr. 25, 2018. Driver’s License: Suspension Appeal; Prejudice; “Extraordinarily extended period of time”

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine whether an operating privilege suspension was imposed in error when delayed due to the failure of the Delaware County Office of Judicial Support to timely notify the Department of Transportation of a conviction.

[Read More]


In Re: Estate of Easterday, 171 A.3d 911(Pa. Super. 2017), appeal dockets 736 and 740 MAL 2017 (cross petitions for allowance)

Allocatur granted Apr. 17, 2018. Death during Pendency of Divorce Proceedings where Post-nuptial Agreement Already Executed; Impact on Insurance Proceeds under 20 Pa.C.S. § 6111.2 & Pension Benefits under ERISA

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine the effect on the right to a decedent’s pension and insurance proceeds where the decedent dies intestate during the pendency of a divorce proceeding from his spouse after the execution of a post-nuptial agreement but before the entry of a final decree in divorce.

[Read More]

Com. v. Bell, 167 A.3d 744 (Pa. Super. 2017), appeal docket 11 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Apr. 5, 2018. DUI; Refusal of Blood Test as Evidence of Guilt

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine whether §1547(e) of the Vehicle Code is violative of the Pennsylvania Constitution and the Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution to the extent that it permits evidence of an arrestee’s refusal to submit a sample of blood for testing without a search warrant as proof of consciousness of guilt at the arrestee’s DUI trial.

[Read More]

In the Interest of: L.J.B., A Minor, 177 A.3d 308 (Pa. Super. 2017), appeal docket 10 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Apr. 3, 2018. Statutory Construction; Prenatal Child Abuse; Addiction

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine whether 23 Pa.C.S. § 6303 et seq. allows a mother to be found a perpetrator of “child abuse” if addicted to drugs when the child is still in the womb.

[Read More]

March 2018

Yanakos v. UPMC, 2017 WL 3168991(Pa. Super. 2017)(unreported),  appeal docket 10 WAP 2018

Allocatur granted March 28, 2018. Statutes of Repose: Article I § 11 “Open Courts” Guarantee; MCARE

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine whether the MCARE Statute of Repose violates the Open Courts guarantees of the Pennsylvania Constitution by depriving some patients of any access to courts, but permitting actions by similarly situated patients.

[Read More]

In re Petition of Adams, 170 A.3d 584 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2017), appeal docket 9 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted March 27, 2018. Land Use; Private Road Act

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine land use issues related to the Private Road Act as decided by the Commonwealth Court.

[Read More]


S & H Transport, Inc. v. City of York174 A.3d 679 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2017), appeal docket 8 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted March 21, 2018. Municipal Business-privilege Tax; Gross Receipts Exemption

The Supreme Court granted allocatur to determine whether a freight broker is permitted to exclude freight delivery charges from its taxable gross receipts under the City of York’s Business Privilege and Mercantile Tax Ordinance.

[Read More]

Fraternal Order of Police Fort Pitt Lodge No. 1 v. City of Pittsburgh, 167 A.3d 245 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2017), appeal docket 7 WAP 2018

Allocatur granted March 13, 2018. Act 47; Direct Appeal of Act 111 Award

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine issues related to the Commonwealth Court’s determination that the FOP was not entitled to direct appeal pursuant to Act 47 of an Act 111 award.

[Read More]

February 2018

Com. v. Perfetto, 169 A.3d 1114 (Pa. Super. 2017), appeal docket 7 EAP 2018 

Allocatur granted Feb. 27, 2018. Compulsory Joinder Rule; Jurisdiction

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania granted allocatur to determine whether the Superior Court erred in determining that the Philadelphia Traffic Court has sole jurisdiction over summary traffic offenses even when those charges are part of a single incident which also includes a misdemeanor and/or felony charges.

[Read More]

JP Morgan Chase Bank N.A. v Taggart, 2017 WL 3669502 (Pa. Super. 2017) (unreported), appeal docket 6 EAP 2018

Allocatur granted Feb. 22, 2018. Foreclosure: notice under Acts 6 and 91; Effect of Dismissal of Earlier Action; Caution to Counsel; Non-conforming Brief; Numerous Issues

Whether a lender/mortgagee whose first complaint in mortgage foreclosure against a borrower/mortgagor was dismissed is required to send a new Notice of Intention to Foreclose pursuant to 41 P.S. § 403(a) (Act 6 Notice) prior to filing a second complaint in mortgage foreclosure.

[Read More]

Slice of Life, LLC v. Hamilton Township, 164 A.3d 633 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2017), appeal docket 7 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Feb. 21, 2018. Zoning; Statutory Construction

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court to determine whether the Commonwealth Court disregarded Albert v. Zoning Hearing Board of North Abington Township by finding that the purely transient use of a property as part of a commercial short-term vacation rental business was a permitted use in a residential zoning district.

[Read More]

Commonwealth v. Adams, 2017 WL 2424726 (Pa. Super. 2017)(unreported), appeal docket 6 WAP 2018

Allocatur granted Feb. 12, 2018. Investigatory Detention; Probable Cause

The Supreme Court granted allocatur to consider whether the trial court erred in denying a motion to suppress when the suspect was detained for pulling into his own business, when such was closed, and thus the stop and subsequent detention was not supported by probable cause or reasonable suspicion of criminal activity.

[Read More]


Reuther v. Delaware Co. Bur. of Elections172 A.3d 738 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2017), appeal docket 6 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Feb. 8, 2018. Election Law; Fatal Defects; Statement of Financial Interests, Petition to Strike; Timeliness

The Supreme Court granted allocatur to review Commonwealth Court’s holding that a write-in candidate’s failure to file a Statement of Financial Interests is not “fatal” in terms of the candidate’s position on the municipal or general election ballot because noncompliance with the regulation is a matter for enforcement by the State Ethics Commission rather than the courts.

[Read More]

January 2018

Williams, et al. v. City of Phila., 164 A.3d 576 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2017), appeal dockets 2 EAP 2018, 3 EAP 2018

Allocatur granted Jan. 30, 2018. Taxation; Preemption; Sterling Act

The Supreme Court granted allocatur to review Commonwealth Court’s conclusion that Philadelphia was empowered to enact the Philadelphia Beverage Tax (PBT) under the Sterling Act and that the City’s authority to do so was neither explicitly nor impliedly preempted by Commonwealth statutes such as the Tax Code and the Local Tax Reform Act.

[Read More]


Commonwealth v. Berryhill2017 WL 3050118 (Pa. Super. 2017)(unreported), appeal docket 4 EAP 2018

Allocatur granted Jan. 30, 2018. Criminal Procedure: Abuse of discretion; Speedy trial; Pa. R. Crim. P 600

The Supreme Court granted allocatur to consider whether the Superior Court abused its discretion regarding excluable calculations under Pa. R. Crim. P. 600.

[Read More]


BouSamra v. Excela Health, 167 A.3d 728 (Pa. Super. 2017), appeal docket 5 WAP 2018

Allocatur granted Jan. 30, 2018. Discovery; Attorney-Client Privilege; Work-Product Doctrine

The Supreme Court granted allocatur to consider whether the Superior Court commit an error of law when holding that a client waives the work-product protection of its counsel’s pre-litigation e-mail by forwarding the e-mail to its public relations consultant, and/or by holding that, to qualify as a privileged person within the attorney-client privilege, a third party must provide legal advice and have the lawyer or client control its work?

[Read More]

Pet. of: Board of Commissioners of Cheltenham Twp., sub nom. Bd. of Commissioners of Cheltenham Twp. v. Hansen-Lloyd, L.P., 166 A.3d 496 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2017), appeal docket 3 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Jan. 29, 2018. Zoning; Special Exception; Applicable Law

This allocatur grant arises from a case of first impression in Bd. of Commissioners of Cheltenham Twp. v. Hansen-Lloyd, L.P., where the Commonwealth Court considered whether, under the Municipalities Planning Code (MPC), the zoning ordinance in effect when a mandatory sketch plan for development was filed applies to a subsequently filed application for special exception, or whether the application for special exception is governed by the zoning ordinance in effect at the time it is filed.

[Read More]

EQT Production Co., v. Borough of Jefferson Hills, 162 A.3d 554 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2017), appeal docket 4 WAP 2018

Allocatur granted Jan. 22, 2018. Land Use and Zoning: Conditional Use; Burden of Proof: Sufficiency of Evidence

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court granted allocatur to determine whether the Commonwealth Court erred as a matter of law by imposing a standard upon the admissibility of objectors’ evidence that effectively eliminates the ability to raise any objection to a land use application based on firsthand experience with a similar use when the proposed use does not already appear within municipal borders?

[Read More]

Com. v. Santiago, 160 A.3d 814 (Pa. Super. 2017), appeal docket 1 EAP 2018

Allocatur granted Jan. 22, 2018. Application of Fruit of the Poisonous Tree Doctrine to In-Court Identification Testimony

The Supreme Court granted allocatur to determine the applicability of the fruit of the poisonous tree doctrine to in-court identification testimony.

[Read More]

C.G. v. J.H., 172 A.3d 43 (Pa. Super. 2017), appeal docket 2 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Jan. 17, 2018. Standing of Same-Sex Partner in Custody Action

The Supreme Court granted allocatur to determine whether the Superior Court erred in affirming the decision of the trial court that a former same-sex partner lacked standing both 1) as a parent and 2) as a party who stood in loco parentis to seek custody of the child born during her relationship with the birth mother where the child was conceived via assisted reproduction with an anonymous sperm donor and the parties lived together as a family unit for the first five years of the child’s life.

[Read More]


Bayview Loan Servicing LLC v. Wicker, 163 A.3d 1039 (Pa. Super. 2017), appeal docket 3 WAP 2018

Allocatur granted Jan. 17, 2018. Hearsay – Business Records Exception; Admissibility of Witness Testimony at Debt Collection Trial

The Supreme Court granted allocatur to determine issues related to the conflict between U.S. Bank v. Pautenis; Boyle v. Steiman and Commonwealth Financial Systems v. Smith as to the admissibility of witness testimony at a debt collection trial

[Read More]


Wolk v. Sch.  Dist. of Lower Merion, 2017 WL 1418445(Pa. Cmwlth.)(unreported), appeal docket 1 MAP 2018

Allocatur granted Jan. 17, 2018. Distinguishing Between Preliminary and Permanent Injunction for Purposes of Appeal; Applicability of Pa. R.A.P 311(a)(4); Requirement to File Post- Trial Motions; Waiver

The Supreme Court granted allocatur to determine issues arising from a lawsuit against School District of Lower Merion attacking a tax increase allegedly in excess of the statutory maximum increase

[Read More]


Com. v. McClelland, 165 A.3d 19 (Pa. Super. 2017), appeal docket 2 WAP 2018

Allocatur granted Jan. 11, 2018.  Hearsay; Preliminary Hearing; Due Process

The Supreme Court granted allocatur to determine whether reliance on hearsay alone to establish a prima facie case at a criminal preliminary hearing violates due process.

[Read More]

Com. v. Monarch, 165 A.3d 945 (Pa. Super. 2017), appeal docket 1 WAP 2018

Allocatur granted Jan. 11, 2018.  Impermissible Enhanced Penalties for Refusal to Consent to Chemical Testing

The Supreme Court granted allocatur to determine whether petitioner in this case was given impermissible enhanced penalties, as expressed in Birchfield v. North Dakota, __ U.S. __, 136 S.Ct. 2160, 195 L.Ed.2d 560 (June 23, 2016), for his refusal to consent to chemical testing?

[Read More]

2017 Allocatur Grant Archive

Allocatur grants present an excellent opportunity for your group or association to advance your legal and policy goals by filing an amicus brief. Participating as an amicus has proven to be an effective method of advising and influencing courts and often can involve far fewer resources than traditional lobbying.

If you are interested or would like more information, contact Kevin McKeon or Dennis Whitaker.